وَرَوىAnd narratedالطَّبَرِيُّ،Al-Tabari,عَنْfromيُونُسَ،Yunus,نَاWe were told byابْنِIbnوَهْبٍ،Wahb,نَاWe were told byابْنِIbnزَيْدٍ.Zayd.
And Al-Tabari narrated from Yunus, We were told by Ibn Wahb, We were told by Ibn Zayd.
فِيRegardingقَوْلِهِ:His saying:{خَالِدِينَ{Abidingفِيهَاin it,مَاas long asدَامَتِthe heavensالسَّمَاوَاتُremainوَالْأَرْضُand the earthإِلَّاexceptمَاwhatشَاءَyour Lord.رَبُّكَ}your Lord.
Regarding His saying: {Abiding in it as long as the heavens and the earth remain, except what your Lord wills.}
فَقَرَأَHe readحَتَّىuntilبَلَغَ:he reached:{عَطَاءً{A giftغَيْرَnotمَجْذُوذٍ}cut off.
He read until he reached: {A gift not cut off.}
فَأَخْبَرَنَاSo he informed usالَّذِيthe one whoشَاءَwilledلِأَهْلِfor the inhabitants ofالجَنَّةِ،Paradise,فَقَالَ:saying:{عَطَاءً{A giftغَيْرَnotمَجْذُوذٍ}cut off.وَلَمْAnd did notيُخْبِرْنَاinform usبِالَّذِيof whatيَشَاءُHe willsلِأَهْلِfor the inhabitants ofالنَّارِ.the Fire.
So he informed us of what He willed for the inhabitants of Paradise, saying: {A gift not cut off.} And did not inform us of what He wills for the inhabitants of the Fire.
وَعَنْAnd aboutالسُّدِّيِّ:Al-Suddi:{إِلَّا{ExceptمَاwhatشَاءَHe willsرَبُّكَ}your Lord.عَنْAboutهَذِهِthisالْآيَةِverseيَوْمَon the dayنَزَلَتْit was revealedكَانُواthey wereيَطْعَمُونَfeedingفِيinالْخُرُوجِ.leaving.
And about Al-Suddi: {Except what your Lord wills.} About this verse, on the day it was revealed, they were feeding during leaving.
قَوْلُهُ:His saying:{خَالِدِينَ{Abidingفِيهَاin itأَبَدًا}forever.}
His saying: {Abiding in it forever.}
ذَكَرَMentionedالْبَغَوِيُّAl-BaghawiعَنْfromعَبْدِAbdالرَّحْمَـٰنِal-RahmanابْنِbinزَيْدٍZaydأَنَّهُthat he said:قَدْIndeedأَخْبَرَنَاhe informed usاللَّهُAllahسُبْحَانَهُthe Exaltedوَتَعَالَىand the Most Highبِالَّذِيabout whatلِأَهْلِfor the inhabitants ofالجَنَّةِ،Paradise,فَقَالَ:saying:{عَطَاءً{A giftغَيْرَnotمَجْذُوذٍ}cut off.وَلَمْAnd did notيُخْبِرْنَاinform usبِالَّذِيof whatيَشَاءُHe willsلِأَهْلِfor the inhabitants ofالنَّارِ.the Fire.
Al-Baghawi mentioned from Abd al-Rahman bin Zayd that he said: Indeed, Allah, the Exalted and Most High, informed us about what He wills for the inhabitants of Paradise, saying: {A gift not cut off.} And did not inform us of what He wills for the inhabitants of the Fire.
وَقَدْAnd indeedرَوَىnarratedعُلَمَاءُthe scholarsالسُّنَّةِof Sunnahوَالْحَدِيثِand Hadithفِيinذَلكَthisآثَارًاare narrationsعَنْfromالْصَّحَابَةِthe Companionsوَالْتَّابِعِينَand the Followersمِثْلَsimilar toمَاwhatرَوَىwas narratedحَرْبٍby Harbالْكَرْمَانِيِّ،the Kermani,وَأَبُوand AbuبَكْرٍBakrالْبَيْهَقِيُّ،Al-Bayhaqi,وَأَبُوand AbuجَعْفَرٍJa'farالطَّبَرِيِّAl-Tabariوَغَيْرِهِمْand othersعَنْfromالْصَّحَابَةِthe Companionsفِيinذَلكَ.that.
And indeed, the scholars of Sunnah and Hadith narrated in this are narrations from the Companions and the Followers similar to what was narrated by Harb the Kermani, Abu Bakr Al-Bayhaqi, Abu Ja'far Al-Tabari, and others from the Companions in that.
وَفِيAnd inالْمُسْنَدِthe Musnadلِلطَّبَرَانِيِّ:of Al-Tabarani:ذَكَرَ فِيهِHe mentioned in it"أَنَّهُthat itيَنْبِتُgrowsفِيهَاin itالْجَرْجِير"the garlic.
And in the Musnad of Al-Tabarani: He mentioned in it "that it grows in it the garlic."
وَحِينََئِذٍAnd at that moment,فَيُحْتَجُّit is arguedعَلَىagainstفَنَائِهَاits annihilationبِالْكِتَابِby the Bookوَالسُّنَّةِ،and the Sunnah,وَأَقْوَالِand the sayingsالصَّحَابَةِof the Companions- مَعَ- whileأَنَّthatالْقَائِلِينَthose who sayبِبَقَائِهَاof its existenceلَيْسَare notمَعَهُمْwith themكِتَابٌ،a Book,وَلَاnorسُنَّةٌa Sunnahوَلَاnorأَقْوَالٌthe sayingsالصَّحَابَةِ -of the Companions -
And at that moment, it is argued against its annihilation by the Book and the Sunnah, and the sayings of the Companions - while those who say of its existence are not with them a Book, nor a Sunnah, nor the sayings of the Companions -.
مِنْهَاAmong thatمَاwhatرَوَىwas narratedحَرْبٍ،by Harb,وَالْبَيْهَقِيِّand Al-Bayhaqi:قَالَ: He saidحَرْبٌHarbالْكَرْمَانِيُّ:the Kermani:سَأَلْتُI askedإِسْحَاقَIshaqعَنْabout
Among that was narrated by Harb, and Al-Bayhaqi: Harb the Kermani said: "I asked Ishaq about.